| Item |  [Barrel of Fish] |
 [Crate of Meat]
|
|---|---|---|
 [Recipe: Spicy Hot Talbuk] |
— | 18.1% |
| [Recipe: Broiled Bloodfin] |
14.8% | — |
| [Recipe: Skullfish Soup] |
13.9% | — |
| [Recipe: Kibler's Bits] |
5.2% | 7.4% |
 [Recipe: Stormchops] |
3.5% | 3.4% |
| [Recipe: Delicious Chocolate Cake] |
2.3% | 2.8% |
| [Recipe: Captain Rumsey's Lager] |
† | † |
| † Since CRL was added later, its relative drop rate is unknown. | ||
Notes:
- Since the recipes never drop twice, over time the recorded rates will continue to lower as player's repeat the quests even after getting the recipes.
- The rates shown (weighted Wowhead & Thottbot averages from 2007-12-03) will be more accurate for players just starting the quests.
Patch 3.2.0 (2009-08-04): Added Recipe: Captain Rumsey's Lager to the possible contents, but for reasons explained in the first note, a relative drop rate cannot be reliably calculated.
