The Red Team is a fighting group led by Captain Andrews. They used to fight against the Blue Team of Captain Thomas.
- They wear the Scarlet Crusade tabard. Whether this means they were Scarlet Crusaders or were just to have a red-colored tabard is unclear.
- During World of Warcraft, members of the Red Team and Blue Team would fight each other, seemingly to train. Unfortunately, after a patch, a bug occurred resulting in Captain Andrews attacking Alliance players. Unfortunately, most players would first encounter Theramore Isle in their early level 30 and upon going near the keep would be set upon by Captain Andrews, who had a remarkable aggro radius due to his high level. In order to prevent him from slaying players, the Red and Blue teams no longer combat each other.