New from scratch
anybody else feels like getting a new start on the page might be the best idea? i actually cant contribute much to retri and holy tactics but am into prot tactics quite a bit. might just start a rewrite soon on prot tactics but i won't try to fit anything into the existing mess Caern 23:24, 22 March 2008 (UTC)
Too much retri
The tactics here are almost completely focused on retri style tactics, and ignore other builds and styles.
Agree - need perspective for tanks, dps and heal
The numbers are wrong...
The numbers in this article asume level 60, I think. I Know that they are too low for level 70. I'll try to fix this up sometime soon. Maybe I'll write some similar info for Prot Pallys so it's more balanced. "..might save you if you're getting beat on by many mobs, but if that's the case, you need to be running away" PAH! Farfromunique 17:37, 19 October 2007 (UTC)
This page need major clean up!!!
It is not only the numbers that have problem. The whole article need major clean up. Like many old pages talking about pally tanks previously, many information about pally tanks here is wrong. I haven't check the paragraph about holy or retrib but I doubt its accuracy too. I helped cleaning up several pages about pally tanks in the last month but I find it difficult to help with this page. What are the aims of this page? What did the authors expect people reading it would gain?
I suggest we can remove those parts that are repetitive with other already existing pages (e.g. prot pallies tanking basics, gear, spec; healadin gear, spec, etc.) but add a links to the relevent pages. The remaining parts will still need to be cleaned up. WakemanCK 05:41, 9 March 2008 (UTC)
I removed those comment about stacking AP for prot and holy pallies as it is too misleading. On further readings, I'm totally confused because under the Heading: Solo strategy, there is a mixture of solo advice and grouping advice. Probably the result of random people adding comments without looking at the whole article. Several of the description of blessings and suggestions about casting sequence are also wrong. The miscellaneous part is a terrible wall of text that I didn't dare to try reading. Someone please help with all these! =/ WakemanCK 06:05, 9 March 2008 (UTC) Bold text
Major cleanup done
Since no one was interested in cleaning it up, I spent yet another day and completed it. I removed/corrected most of the wrong or out-of-date things. For the parts about party and PvP, since there are pages covered them much better, I either moved the paragraph to the respective pages, or removed it if out-of-date. Hope you find it looks better now. WakemanCK 09:01, 5 April 2008 (UTC)
Pally tactics section
On the aoe grinding section, there appears to be a mistake, which directly contradicts the Palladin AOE grinding page. It says use seal of righteousness on this page, but Light/wisdom on the AOE grinding page. I am pretty sure what is on the AOE grinding page is correct, as with righteousness, against several opponents you will die very quickly. WIth Light, and reckoning, you can get some heallth back approx every 2 seconds, and hold out far better. I changed it but it was changed back. Who is right?Warden Shadowsong (talk) 17:32, 3 August 2008 (UTC)
- This is simple. There is no absolute wrong or right on this topic. Beginner tanks may use Seal of Light/Wisdom more. Kara-exit or higher level tanks normally do not worry about having a few mobs hitting them for 1 or 2 minutes, so Seal of the Righteousness help them to kill a bit faster, and only change to SoL/SoW when their health/mana is getting low. WakemanCK (talk) 04:17, 5 August 2008 (UTC)
- Added some clarification to the article. Hope it is clear enough now. Anyway, a lot of thing is going to change when WotLK out, so the article will need some major changes in a few months time. WakemanCK (talk) 04:50, 5 August 2008 (UTC)