Talk:Tides of Darkness
Sort of redundant
This can be merged with either The Alliance of Lordaeron since it's the exact same text. Or perhaps make this page redirect to the game Warcraft II: Tides of Darkness. --Magnus 19:15, 10 December 2006 (EST)
- As much as I admire all of your work, and respect your opinion, I think you are wrong. This page is clearly showcasing the new novel and NOT about the game or in game novel. Obviously this page will be filled out more as time progresses and will be vital to catalog the novels publishing. (Sern 14:11, 15 March 2007 (EDT))
Before or after War of the Ancients?
Reading Tides of Darkness, there's several significant deviations from the game. Most notably, in the novel the elves and dwarves join the Alliance much later than they did in the game (the second Alliance mission for the elves).
The differences can be explained as part of Rhonin/Krasus's interference in the War of the Ancients trilogy, but the question is… which happened when? I'm almost tempted to say that the book should be the original version, and the game the post-time travel version. Why? In the trilogy, the dwarves, furbolg, and others are brought into the war to help the night elves. Seeing the success of that, it would make sense that later on down the line, they would be willing to repeat that, as opposed to the reluctant involvement depicted in the novel.
Does anybody else have any thoughts? ATimson 17:31, 7 September 2007 (UTC)
- Do we even know how much time passed between first and second/third mission of the game? I don't think it stated specifically. Also in warcraft II, it was explained to be a "mysterious Elves of Silvermoon have sent a contingent of Archers south to survey the supposed Orcish threat for themselves." The elves don't actually join the Alliance until the third mission according to the narration.
- Also is the battle even covered in the novel? It could have been deemed non-essential to the main plot, since it doesn't include any famous heros, and is a fairly mundane event, and left out of the novel. But it could have still occured as one of the battles during the war, just not one of the important ones.Baggins 17:36, 7 September 2007 (UTC)
- Additionally, Brann's accounts, which make a few references to events from second timeline, like death of Hakkar the Houndmaster during the War of the Ancients (He has references to other versions of the accounts too, he kind of blends them down the middle), also discusses some high elves and dwarves with the alliance before the main bulk joined.Baggins 17:47, 7 September 2007 (UTC)
Actually, I'd say the main change are that the Gnomes and Goblins are nowhere to be found. The gnomes can be explained away by saying that there involvement in the war was helping out Ironforge (Though Brann says that the gnomes were essential to winning the war) but the goblins are just gone.
Anyway, I doubt that the WotA trilogy factors into this. They've already made changes to what we've seen in the game, and the Blue Dragonflight aside we've never really gotten an idea of how Krasus and Rhonin affected the timeline. --Austin P 21:48, 13 September 2007 (UTC)
The goblins were definitely involved though, the author probably just didn't deem them important enough for the details he wanted to cover, rather than being outright removed from history. There are nough references to their involvement in plenty of other sources, including Brann.Baggins 07:07, 22 October 2007 (UTC)
By the way it seems the six year gap between Warcraft I and II was shortened in the novel. I got the impression the Horde invaded Lordaeron some months after they conquered Stormwind. However this creates another inconsistency in the storyline since earlier sources have kept the six year gap (and even the intro movie to Warcraft II mentions it) (Omega2010 (talk) 02:32, 6 June 2008 (UTC))
- Warcraft 3 shortened it to a one year gap, which long precedes the novelization. -- Dark T Zeratul (talk) 08:29, 6 June 2008 (UTC)
Actually most of blizzard's timelines have a two year gap beteween Warcraft I and Warcraft II. Blizzard's online timeline doesn't actually specifically list when the first war was over, only when it began. The war lasted approximately 4 years in other timelines IIRC. In other words two years between the games.Baggins (talk) 07:13, 2 July 2008 (UTC)