Tyler can be found in the War Quarter in the Undercity.
Along with Edward, he fights against other NPCs summoned by Brother Malach: starting with three human captives, then a ghoul and a zombie, and at the end an abomination.
- Tyler stands near a number of other characters in Undercity, including Edward, Richard Van Brunt, Robert Gossom, Andrew Hartwell, Riley Walker, Chloe Curthas, and Marla Fowler. Many if not all of these characters are references to the movie Fight Club, either using the movie's characters' first names, or the names of their respective actors. In the case of Tyler, a Tyler was also seen punching with a Robert in chapter 1 of the undead campaign of Warcraft III: Reign of Chaos.